Welcome to BirdForum, the internet's largest birding community with thousands of members from all over the world. The forums are dedicated to wild birds, birding, binoculars and equipment and all that goes with it.
Please register for an account to take part in the discussions in the forum, post your pictures in the gallery and more.
- Birding
- Hummingbirds
- Thread startertng03_22
- Start dateJul 31, 2014
More options
Who Replied?
T
tng03_22
New member
- Jul 31, 2014
- #1
Yesterday, I saw a tiny creature that looked and acted like a hummingbird. I remember as a child seeing hummingbirds float from flower to flower with their long, thin beaks extending into the center of each bloom. I live in Germany, and have not seen a hummingbird for a long time. But yesterday I was thrilled to see what I thought was a hummingbird. Today, after a bit of research, I found a video that matches the description of what I saw. Turns out I witnessed a hummingbird hawk moth, and although rare, it was a disappointment. Attached is a picture with a circle around the moth. Zoom in to see it a little better. Sorry it is not the clearest picture.
Attachments
T
TFM70
Well-known member
- Jul 31, 2014
- #2
Don't feel bad. I have seen many Hummers, but the first Hawk Moth was still very nice. I wish they were more common here.
Bird_Bill
Well-known member
- Jul 31, 2014
- #3
The resemblance in flight to a hummingbird is uncanny. The 17 years I've been in this location, have seen 3 of the Sphingidae family, or hawk moths, clearwings, hummingbird moths, etc. in the yard. Relative rarity, and mostly nocturnal/crepuscular activity here, makes it a genuine treat to see one.
Chris D
Well-known member
- Jul 31, 2014
- #4
Have seen the same high in the Sierra. High up in elevation - I mean. Always on heather.
ptickner
Well-known member
- Jul 31, 2014
- #5
There is a local store with photos and paintings from local artists with a very nice photo labeled "Hummingbird on Lupine". The only problem is that it is clearly a moth! I pointed this out once to the shop owner, who it turns out was also the photographer, and I was quite rudely told "I think I know what a hummingbird is". I just smiled walked out.
Chris D
Well-known member
- Aug 1, 2014
- #6
Awesome.
Bird_Bill
Well-known member
- Aug 1, 2014
- #7
Per my first post, seen 3 in yard. Last, being one that flew into the house this past May. For few seconds, early in the morning, for all practical purposes there was a hummingbird flying around in here, until I fully focused on it. Couldn't get a pic of it in flight, indoors or out. Did coax it to a box, managed a few frames, and released into predawn. Even at rest, tail end, & general profile are striking, compared to a hummer.
Attachments
Peter C.
...just zis guy, you know?
- Aug 7, 2014
- #8
ptickner said:
There is a local store with photos and paintings from local artists with a very nice photo labeled "Hummingbird on Lupine". The only problem is that it is clearly a moth! I pointed this out once to the shop owner, who it turns out was also the photographer, and I was quite rudely told "I think I know what a hummingbird is". I just smiled walked out.
3
It's always so funny to come across a true, dyed-in-the-wool, supremely confident ignoramus. In my experience, I've found that their self-confidence varies in direct proportion to their ignorance. In University, we had a name for these people: know-nothing experts.
NUMENIOS
Don't understand me too quickly, please!
- Sep 1, 2014
- #9
The word and the thing
Peter C. said:
3
It's always so funny to come across a true, dyed-in-the-wool, supremely confident ignoramus. In my experience, I've found that their self-confidence varies in direct proportion to their ignorance. In University, we had a name for these people: know-nothing experts.
But you can look at it from another point too: The word is not the thing - and the thing is not the word. Although we constantly mix them up, they have nothing to do with each other, and if someone chooses to call a moth "a hummingbird" he's free to do so; the -bird at the end doesn't mean anything either, just think of the ladybird.
There is only one limitation to that approach: You can use any name you like - but don't expect anyone to understand you!
Ivan
ptickner
Well-known member
- Sep 3, 2014
- #10
NUMENIOS said:
if someone chooses to call a moth "a hummingbird" he's free to do so; the -bird at the end doesn't mean anything either, just think of the ladybird.
There is only one limitation to that approach: You can use any name you like - but don't expect anyone to understand you!
Ivan
I'm a little confused by this. A hummingbird is different from a moth, and in this case the "bird" at the end does mean something. It is a bird. The point being made in this thread is that some moths are mistaken for hummingbirds, but they are still moths. If someone chooses erroneously to declare a moth to be a hummingbird I don't really see that as a freedom of speech issue. Sure, I have the right to say that 2+2=5, but that doesn't mean it is correct.
C
coal tit
COAL TIT
- Sep 3, 2014
- #11
Hummingbird hawkmoth
Bird_Bill said:
Per my first post, seen 3 in yard. Last, being one that flew into the house this past May. For few seconds, early in the morning, for all practical purposes there was a hummingbird flying around in here, until I fully focused on it. Couldn't get a pic of it in flight, indoors or out. Did coax it to a box, managed a few frames, and released into predawn. Even at rest, tail end, & general profile are striking, compared to a hummer.
Super picture
Of the hummingbird hawkmoth at rest I have never seen a picture of this
Kind before quite unusual moths beautiful camouflage too.
NUMENIOS
Don't understand me too quickly, please!
- Sep 3, 2014
- #12
Clarification
ptickner said:
I'm a little confused by this. A hummingbird is different from a moth, and in this case the "bird" at the end does mean something. It is a bird. The point being made in this thread is that some moths are mistaken for hummingbirds, but they are still moths. If someone chooses erroneously to declare a moth to be a hummingbird I don't really see that as a freedom of speech issue. Sure, I have the right to say that 2+2=5, but that doesn't mean it is correct.
Hello, my post was mainly humorous - I thought the last sentence would make that clear.
However, it is still true that words are basically arbitrary; they get their meaning only by agreement, and especially when it comes to abstract terms you'll find that the meanings various people link to a certain term can and do differ enormously (just think of words like "god", "freedom", "love", "happiness" - they are obviously not the same for everyone). Mathematics are different, they don't depend on agreement. On the other hand, the language of mathematics DOES depend on agreement: in the decimal system 8+8=16, but in the hexadecimal system 8+8=... 10! (here the first digit "1" assumes the value of 16 - 16, now in the decimal system again)
But to get back on the track: YOU know that the -bird in "hummingbird" refers to a biological taxon and the -bird in "ladybird" does not. But if someone does not know it, he might think that the hummingBIRD is an insect just as the ladyBIRD is. This is a very simple example of the rather complex matter I was hinting at; only I don't think this is the place to go into it any further.
Ivan
Last edited:
T
tng03_22
New member
- Nov 9, 2014
- #13
Thank you for all of the replies! I was happy to find that hummingbird hawk moths are a rare sight, so I was able to experience something beautiful and uncommon. And now I know there are different types of hawk moths, too. When I took this picture, a man approached and told me it was not a hummingbird, but he could not remember the name of this "insect." I, too, replied that I was sure it was a hummingbird 3
And now I know.
